Ice storm season is here.Limb on the roof or a tree across the drive in Broken Arrow? Don't wait on it.Emergency tree help
Broken Arrow Tree CareEmergency tree service Emergency tree help

My neighbor's tree fell on my house. Who pays?

It feels like it should be their problem. Usually it isn't, unless the tree was already dead. Here's how it generally works.

A fallen tree resting on playground equipment in a yard

This is general information, not legal advice. Your insurer, and an attorney if it comes to that, are the ones to ask about your situation.

A healthy tree that fell in a storm

Generally, your own homeowner insurance covers damage to your property, even when the tree was your neighbor's. A healthy tree knocked down by wind, ice or a tornado is usually treated as an act of nature, not anyone's fault. Your neighbor's insurance covers their property.

A tree that was dead or obviously dangerous

This is where the neighbor can be responsible. If the tree was dead, rotten or visibly failing, and the owner knew or reasonably should have known, damage from it may be their responsibility. Your insurer may pay your claim and then try to recover from them.

That's why documentation matters. If your neighbor has a dead tree that can reach your house, put your concern in writing now, with dated photos. See my neighbor's dead tree.

What to do right now

  1. Make it safe. Get people away from it, stay clear of wires, call PSO for lines.
  2. Photograph everything, including the tree's stump or break. A rotten break is evidence.
  3. Call your own insurer and let them sort out who pays.
  4. Tell your neighbor, calmly. They need to call their insurer too.
  5. Get the tree off your house so the damage doesn't spread.

Who removes the tree?

Often each owner deals with the part of the tree on their own property, through their own insurance. When it's on your house, don't wait to argue about it. Get the weight off first.

Common questions

Is my neighbor responsible if their tree falls on my house?

Usually not if the tree was healthy and a storm knocked it down. Possibly yes if it was dead or dangerous and they knew.

Who pays when a neighbor's tree falls on my fence?

Generally the same rules: your insurance for your fence, unless the tree was dead or neglected.

Who pays if my tree falls on my neighbor's house?

Generally their insurance covers their house if your tree was healthy. If your tree was dead, you may be responsible. Another reason to deal with dead trees early.

Emergency tree help